Sharks denied victory in Sydney

Daniel Halangahu © Gallo Images
The Sharks were denied their first victory of this year’s Vodacom Super 14, when the Waratahs held out for a close 25-21 victory in Sydney on Saturday.

Blow-by-blow scoring

But while they were beaten, the Sharks can feel greatly aggrieved by a number of home town decisions by Australian referee Paul Marks, who refused to award a crucial penalty try when Kurtley Beale committed a professional foul that denied them a try two minutes before the end.

Sharks captain John Smit was perplexed with Marks’s calls -- which included two yellow cards early on in the match -- and a late penalty for obstruction which had the visitors shaking their heads that ended their challenge for the match.

However, in a match where things definitely didn’t go their way, the Sharks can hold their heads high after their disappointing start to the season. On this form, they definitely will turn the corner soon with the amount of character in their side.

The crucial call that killed them though, came shortly before the final whistle. Stefan Terblanche broke on the blind side, and had only to send the pass out to Ryan Kankowski for the winning try when Beale stepped between them and slapped the ball down in deliberate fashion.

While Marks gave a yellow card for a deliberate knock down, he was deaf to the Sharks cries for a penalty try, especially as there was no defender ahead of Kankowski and the try would most certainly have been scored. Marks could only have been swayed by the fact the incident occurred on the 22 metre line.

The ensuing penalty against the Sharks when they were forming a maul was equally perplexing, and virtually handed the Waratahs the game on a platter.

Still, after being down to 13 men early on, the Sharks fought bravely to get themselves back within a score of winning.

The scoreline was six-all when the first yellow was flashed. Jannie du Plessis, the same player penalised at the end in the lineout, stuck his foot out to deliberately trip Danile Halangahu, who was following his own kick, and got ten minutes for his troubles.

Whether it was worth a yellow card was debatable, but even Smit argued with Marks a minute later when Andy Goode was flashed a similar card for slowing down the ball on his own line.

Yet down to 13 men, the Sharks excelled in their resolve, and actually took the lead through a superb piece of individual brilliance by Ryan Kankowski. The big No 8 floated up as the Waratahs took a quick lineout and swooped in before Halangahu could receive the pass to run in untouched for the try.

Ruan Pienaar added a penalty to give them a 14-6 lead, but without the necessary personnel they were always going to struggle, with Halangahu finding a gap close to the line to pull one back for the Waratahs.

Tom Carter drove over the line from close range to give the Waratahs a 18-14 lead and Tatafu Polota-Nau showed his strength to power under the posts early in the second half.

With that try, it seemed the Sharks were buried, but they found new resolve and battered their way into the Waratahs half to keep the ball and were rewarded when the gap opened up for Adrian Jacobs to score.

Then on the attack and searching for the win, they had the perfect opportunity which Beale ruined, and had to be content with a bonus point for finishing within seven points for their efforts.

Scorers:
Waratahs
- tries: Daniel Halangahu, Tom Carter, Tatafa Polota-Nau. Conversions: Berrick Barnes (2). Penalties: Barnes (2)
Sharks - try: Ryan Kankowski, Adrian Jacobs. Conversion: Andy Goode Penalties: Andy Goode, Ruan Pienaar. Drop Goal: Goode.

Read more on the Super 14 page.


Comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.
by snormossel March 6, 2010 20:20 GMT
Can one ban a referee for a few games due to incompetence?
Report this comment
by Raymond Durrett March 6, 2010 20:37 GMT
OMG...Paul Marks you SHOCKER! How the hell he allowed the build up to the Tahs 2nd try to continue is also a total mistery with Robinson clearly losing the ball in contact about 4\5 phases before the try. I know reffing is a tough job and I normally steer clear of commenting on refs but when they bring the game into such disrepute it's only right that they be singled out as totally not up to the job...this is after all a PROFESSIONAL game now!
Report this comment
by Travis Mcgarry March 6, 2010 22:28 GMT
Come now Sharks, this season is testing your character, keep your heads high, build your confidence and come back twice as strong..."Some times you win, and some times you learn. " Thanks for still making it easy to be proud of our team.
Report this comment
by william green March 7, 2010 01:35 GMT
Some form of disciplinary action should be carried out against this display of obvious bias by a home-town referee. It will be absolutely outrageous if he is allowed to continue to blow any further games. It seems that the refs from Australia are always the ones who are caught in the middle of refereeing controversies. The last one was Matt Godard, but it seems he has'nt learnt anything and continues his controversy, but now as the TMO.
Report this comment
by Richard Gamlin March 7, 2010 05:33 GMT
I have watched this a number of times and dont see how he deliberatley knoked the ball "down". To me it looks like a genuine attempt to intercept the pass.Obviously failed however if that is a penalty try then intercepts will be very hard to come by in the future .I thonk the correct call would have been knock on. not a tah supporter just a rugby nut...
Report this comment
by SuperBru March 7, 2010 22:51 GMT
Yes penalty try 100%.One has to feel sorry for the clownfish,its just not happening for them.
Report this comment
by Kobus De Jager March 8, 2010 02:54 GMT
ref is a joke.....but he will go on to destroy many more games, i bet
Report this comment
by yardbirds63 March 8, 2010 04:13 GMT
I really think they should go back to the "nuetral" refs that the S - 14 had 2 yrs ago........
Report this comment
by yardbirds63 March 8, 2010 04:13 GMT
I really think they should go back to the "nuetral" refs that the S - 14 had 2 yrs ago........
Report this comment
by Pdivvy March 8, 2010 13:07 GMT
And Steve Walsh.... Gets fired by NZRU for drinking to much. Rehired by aussies. This weekend he yellow cards Lions front row , then check out the wink and smile to Brumbies front row players straight after .....Fking Dodgey. What was that Steve , a 'you owe me a double bundy and coke later ' wink . Bring back neutral refs !!!!
Report this comment
by agata March 9, 2010 00:34 GMT
Are you guys kidding me? Terblanche should have passd it earlier! Kankowski would have scored easily! Teaches him right for not knowing how to draw and pass correctly, he had terrible technique. Mildly forgivable if he was a winger, but he is a fullback! Also, I find it pretty amusing that South Africans are complaining about professional fouls. Some of my best friends are South Africans and even they can admit that you guys are the best in the world at them! If you were the better team you would have won. I'm sorry but you can't cry foul at the ref EVERY game. Do you serieusly think the guy is crooked? In professional sports these days?? Really hard to believe. I'm sure the 50/50 decisions go the home teams way WHEREVER you are playing. You can't tell me that the ridiculously loud crouds in SA don't effect 50/50 decisions? Sharks are a great team and I'm sure they will show great character throughout the rest of the season. To be honest, you guys are more enjoyable to watch than the Tahs anyway! (not saying much)
Report this comment
by Travis Mcgarry March 9, 2010 01:01 GMT
I agree with Richard, watched it over and over and he clearly tried for the intercept not a knock down, if Terblanche passed a fraction earlier a try for Kankowski, fraction later a try for the Tahs. Don't get me wrong it devastated me when it happened, but us fans need to take a leaf from the team and just suck it up, its part of the game...come Sharks win this weekend by enough that the refs have no control and your fans don't look like whining school kids on media zone. Proud of the team always, play hard this weekend boys,build your confidance and the rest will follow. Go Sharks
Report this comment
by Joe Bartell March 9, 2010 01:42 GMT
Beale was trying for intercept- he had a stroll to try ahead of him! Terblanche is to blame for bad timing. A penalty try from 22 out?- c'mon, with the speed of some of these guys in the chase? Add a Ref to the pitch- one for the advantage line and one for back play. Or let the TMO adjudicate the entire pitch and then the match will last 3 hrs. Missed/bad calls are part of the game.
Report this comment


© SuperSport.com