The 53 metre heartbreaker

Morne Steyn © Gallo Images
From Mick Cleary, rugby correspondent, The Daily Telegraph.

Tell me South Africans, what will you remember from the 2009 Lions series?

That the Lions were bright, inventive, clever, brazen and imaginative, full of running or ideas?

Or that Morne Steyn smacked over a 53metre heartbreaker with the very last kick of the second test to clinch the series?

Do you know what? I have an inkling it might be the latter. As time goes by that impression will grow stronger and stronger, just as Jeremy Guscott's drop goal in Durban in 1997 has been replayed time and again. Little mention has ever been made of the fact that the Springboks themselves made all the running in that series but were undone by their crass selections and coaching.

Fair enough. To the victors the spoils and all that. The losers usually have no right of reply, no claim on a viewpoint, no status. Well, it's about time we changed all that. For if these Lions are not recognised for their true value, then it would be a betrayal of everything this tour is supposed to be about.

These Lions must not be seen simply as losers. There is to be no denying the fact that South Africa were the better team. The scoreboard tells us that. If there was one aspect in which they were markedly superior it was in their finishing. They had chances and they took them. The Lions had chances, particularly in the first test, and blew them.

In almost every other regard, though, the Lions had the beating of their opponents. And that fact must never be forgotten. For if it is, then the whole future of Lions tours will be placed in doubt. If our only reckoner is to be a simple entry in the history books - South Africa 2 British and Irish Lions 0 ( as things stand ) – then we will be doing a great tradition a profound disservice. That entry in the records might even become 3-0, and most certainly will unless some of the injured Lions make a miraculous recovery over the next few days, and pretty soon there will be all manner of people wondering if Lions tours can carry on because the strain on resources is so great and the return seemingly so little.

So, it's time to shut those people up. And do you know who can make the most telling comments of all – you, the Springbok supporters. If all you do is jump and shout and revel in your side's victory, then you will be letting down rugby itself. There should be celebration but no gloating. There should be joy but no triumphalism. There should be recognition of the wonderful captain you have in John Smit and the manner in which he draws the best from himself and those around him, but no sneering at the way in which the Lions struggled at various times.

Be bold and be generous. Raise a glass to Ian McGeechan for what he has managed to do in five short weeks. Raise a cheer for the likes of Jamie Roberts and Brian O'Driscoll, for the splendid efforts of Simon Shaw, too, winning his first Lions cap after 17 previous attempts and at the age of 35. And let's toast above all else a quite magnificent test match, one of the finest in living memory for its drama, for its heart and its soul, and, yes, even for its theatrical finish.

And if we do all that, then rest assured the Lions will be back here in 12 years time looking for revenge.

To read more of Mick Cleary go to www.telegraph.co.uk

Read more on the British & Irish Lions page.


Comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.
by Gunnar June 29, 2009 13:22 GMT
I agree with you..., gloating is for the hooligans of english soccer....rugby is a religion in South Africa...we do NOT gloat at guest members of the congregation. when they fall short...we lift them up and invite them in again...in 12 years time:-) GO BOKKE and to ther LIons...you bring out the best in the Springboks...thanks:-)
Report this comment
by George Mouton June 29, 2009 13:56 GMT
Great Article, end of the day it's all about the Rugby... But for a lot of us it is also about shutting those big mouths from the north up, not by foul play but with great competitive full on HARD clean Rugby....!!! And after we shake hands and we all have a beer together afterwards... no hard feelings...!!! Up the Boks and thanx to the Lions for being great competitors...!!! Hope to see you back in SA in 2021...
Report this comment
by Addi June 29, 2009 16:30 GMT
I fully agree Mick and acknowledge that both teams played superbly. I enjoyed every minute of it! I want to ask the Lion players and their supporters to acknowledge that the springboks played well and deservedly have taken the series. As of now, I haven't read much about that and pls read the comments from PDV that the lion players haven't even applauded the victory. I get the funny taste in my mouth and it partly comes from not accepting that they've been beaten by a better team. Actually, I mostly read about why they lost, excuses over excuses and not that a better team won. You know, the springboks were beaten in the tri-nations last year, hey, so what. Applaud the winning team, dust yourself off and start all over again. That's what the guys have done.
Report this comment
by jdesousa June 29, 2009 17:45 GMT
Mick, You are not an elected or appointed spokesmen for rugby, be it players, supporters or the unoins. You are a rugby corresponded right?. A proffesional one at that, i hope? Now report on rugby events and the actual games. The lions tour is not an editorial event. Blogs are more suited to your emotional style. Respect was duly acknowledged on both sides before and after the 2nd test. No one said the 2009 lions are "loser", yes they just lost the test series. No one needs to shut up, you as a journalist should know that. I say both sides enjoyed the rugby contest, which true rugby players fans will always relish. These are highly combative test series. Not just in South African. My toast are for the BOKKE, the victors and cheers to the LIONS for putting up a great fight. Looking forward to the last test.
Report this comment
by J-B June 29, 2009 18:07 GMT
I think the lions should tour argentina for 2013, so this way they'll at least have a series win
Report this comment
by jdesousa June 29, 2009 18:41 GMT
Jeremy, I agree fully. I also beleive that the lions should follow the argentinia 2013 tour with the a Fiji, Samoa and Tonga in 2018.
Report this comment
by rod mullins June 29, 2009 19:02 GMT
What do I remember about the series? 2 great games, definitely among the best I've seen, won by the Boks and lost by the Lions. I agree that the Lions were unlucky at times, but they didn't really put the foot down when the games were there for the taking - that was their failure. Bad referees, bullies, dirty players - those are challenges faced by all rugby teams, the Lions are not the only ones on the receiving end and the Boks are not the only culprits. He who overcomes wins. Mick I've read a lot of your writing and I have to say that in general it is one-eyed and whiney along with the rest of the NH fans and press (I exclude Scotland and France). Along with South African fans maybe you guys should also learn a lesson..
Report this comment
by Derek Stuart June 29, 2009 20:58 GMT
Good article Mick BUT now you can write one to the people of Britain and Ireland asking them to applaud the rugby the Boks played ,the challenges we faced by a committed and intense Lions effort and a series win. Ask them to acknowledge and congratulate the victors and talk about their disappointments and feelings of being hard done by somewhat seperately. It is hard to be a encouraging force when there hs been little to no acceptance and appreciation of the Boks win. Its a bit of tit for tat,but both sides need to show respect and appreciation. And i'm talking about the media and fans not the players aside from Phillips who also comes across as a sore loser who wants to win against 14 men rather.
Report this comment
by Alan Schapiro June 30, 2009 04:05 GMT
Mick, you're absolutely right! Except for one comment....Springbok fans are true lovers of the game and they will respect this Lions squad and the coach for the way they came and played outstanding rugby after only a short time to get to know each other and play together. The fact is that the 'Boks were lucky....but for a few sloppy errors and some devastating injuries, the Lions would be even steven and, yes, might even be two up! Come on, "Bok fans, give credit where it's due to the Lions and applaud their fine character and effort!
Report this comment
by jdesousa June 30, 2009 04:41 GMT
Alan sHAPIRO, Credit has already been duly provided BOTH ON AND OFF THE FIELD, but unfortunately not acknowledged by the LIONS MANGEMENT, PLAYERS OR THE BLOG FANS!. What part did you not read OR UNDERSTAND! ONE MORE TIME YOU GOT THE STATS ON YOUR SIDE WE HAVE THE SERIES WIN ON OUR SIDE. Your team lost the series, now give the BOKKE the respect they deserve AND GET ON WITH YOUR LIFE.
Report this comment
by James Swindells June 30, 2009 07:23 GMT
Excellent article. I totally agree about the gloating comments. Its a poor sportsman / sportswoman / team who degrades their opposing team players after they have won a game or series. What happened to the healthy competition and sportsmanship of the 70's?
Report this comment
by James Oliver June 30, 2009 10:36 GMT
In fairness after the second test especially, I praised the lions for the way they played, it was one of the best tests that I have seen. What irritates me is that every time John Smit or PdV has had a post match interview they have given credit to the lions. I have heard only one positive remark from one of the lions players but not from the captain or coach. I only hear things like how they should have one or how they were cheated or how the ref was one eyed etc. The lions camp should pay some respect to the Boks as the Boks have done to them. So don't you dare tell us to more gracious considering you guys are being the sour grapes in the bunch!
Report this comment
by James Oliver June 30, 2009 10:38 GMT
PS,. I have no problem giving credit where credit is due, but I expect it back when when it is earned and the Boks have earned every bit!
Report this comment
by thomas ash June 30, 2009 12:14 GMT
I completely agree with you James, the Boks deserve credit for the series win. Most of the press after the win over the weekend has been about Schalk and Bakkies, Div and how unluck the Lions are to have lost both test matches. Seems like the media and the Lions feel that if they never admit it and keep talking about other issues, then the series loss will be forgotten... This probably isn't whats going on, but it surely comes across that way.
Report this comment
by Jacques Knotter July 1, 2009 07:07 GMT
I am not a fan of yours Mick,but I will have to say that this was one of the best Lions teams I have ever seen.it was just unfortunate that they came at a time when the Springboks have also become one of the best team combinations in the world today.
Report this comment
by jdesousa July 1, 2009 07:11 GMT
James Rindells comment reposted for BY ME FOR clarification...he calls it gloating i call it "historical fact" 'Excellent article. I totally agree about the gloating comments. Its a poor sportsman / sportswoman / team who degrades their opposing team players after they have LOST a game or series. What happened to the healthy competition and sportsmanship of the 70's?
Report this comment
by Duncan Olds July 1, 2009 10:05 GMT
HANG ON! I haven't finished reading your article yet but I'm going to comment right now on your opening statements... No one is denying the Lions as formidable opponents so don't go throwing your toys around by saying we don't respect the Lions game. Its' a competitive sport and we scrapped through to win the second test right at the end - DEAL WITH IT!!! Both teams were hot under the collar on the pitch and the intensity was electric. That was to be expected - no? Don't be a stereotypical sore English loser and put your own team down. They have had a fantastic tour with the exception of the 2 test losses. South Africa have an abundance of talent which is hidden by the government forces influencing our game. We are playing tactical games on and off the pitch! Lets see what happens in the 3rd test...
Report this comment